Security Dilemma 1

  • Is a concept from Structural Realism, where Kenneth Waltz says states must increase power to gain security
    • But end it ends up making other states less secure
  • Security Dilemma is the difficult choice states have to make between choosing to continue building their power and stopping.
  • As the International System being anarchic the structure forces states to build power or become extinct. However, no matter the choice, it always end in war.
  • States A cannot stay in one place or risk being invaded by state B who builds up their power.
    • State B will take an opportunity to take out their enemy (State A)
  • No matter what you choose to do you will be end with the bad result of War
    • That’s why its a dilemma

Small States

  • Small States are more vulnerable in the Anarchical international system
  • Due to their inferior capabilities to produce security solely through internal measures
    • Small states can’t increase their security through their own actions
    • They get security through larger powers: either balancing, neutrality, alliance, or Shelter Theory
  • Structure of IS is the main factor, not what small states do themselves
  • Therefore, according to Waltz, small states must
    • bandwagon with great powers
    • Balancing: build alliance with smaller states

References

Footnotes

  1. IS405 Lecture on Realism